/a/ winter 2014 roster survey results
CURRENT PLAYERS
As usual up or down votes were taken on the current 23 players of the roster. Based on the results the cutoff was set at 58% for approval, which was pretty close to the last poll's 55%. In addition, also like last time the top 4 were Accel, Bebop, Inferno Cop, and Mugi, and again they all got over 80% approval. Since I am usually looking for ways to make the poll a little shorter, we're going to just call them permanently on the team and not go through the bother of getting their 'yes' votes from 7 out of every 8 people that take the poll.
+------------------+------+--------+ | name | vote | pct | +------------------+------+--------+ | Accelerator | 179 | 0.9179 | | Inferno Cop | 175 | 0.8974 | | Mugi | 174 | 0.8923 | | Cowboy Bebop | 172 | 0.8821 | ========PERMANENT STATUS LINE======== | JoJo | 153 | 0.7846 | | Anno | 151 | 0.7744 | | King of GETs | 149 | 0.7641 | | Tomoko | 148 | 0.7590 | | The Rei | 147 | 0.7538 | | Boku no Pico | 146 | 0.7487 | | Kenshiro | 139 | 0.7128 | | Meguca | 138 | 0.7077 | | Kamina | 136 | 0.6974 | | Colossal Titan | 133 | 0.6821 | | Yamakan | 132 | 0.6769 | | Best Girl Thread | 125 | 0.6410 | ========CUT LINE===================== | JOHJ | 112 | 0.5744 | | Hora Hora Hora | 112 | 0.5744 | | Grumpy Jii-san | 107 | 0.5487 | | Korbo | 103 | 0.5282 | | 8man | 99 | 0.5077 | | ERU ERUFU | 75 | 0.3846 | | Monokuma | 66 | 0.3385 | +------------------+------+--------+
NEW PLAYERS
7 spots were opened in the current player voting. Here are the players that will replace them, and the ones that also got some support in the voting.
Made the cut
- >ROTOSCOPING (Board meme/Aku no Hana)
- DATABASE DATABASE (Log Horizon)
- Guillotine Gorilla (Samurai Flamenco)
- One-Punch Man (One-Punch Man)
- Renge-chon (Non Non Biyori)
- Ryuuko Matoi (Kill la Kill)
- TADA BANRI (Golden Time)
Good support but missed the cut
- Bukki (PreCure)
- Emiya Shirou (Fate/Stay Night)
- Kaiki Deishuu (Monogatari)
- KUBOOOOOO (Board meme/mangaka)
- Lelouch (Code Geass)
- Semen Demon (Board meme/Milky Holmes)
Minor support
- Dark Flame Master (Chuu2)
- Fairy (Jinrui wa suitai Shimashita)
- Gintoki Sakata (Gintama)
- Hug Your Imouto (meta thread)
- HYPER OATS (Psycho-Pass)
- Kircheis (LoGH)
- Space Dandy (Space Dandy)
- Tsubasa (Captain Tsubasa)
- Urobutcher (writer/serial fictional character torturer)
- Yukari (Girls und Panzer)
- Yura Yamato (C3-bu)
ANTHEM POLL RESULTS
- "Red Ambassadress" (Eva 2.22 OST) - retained
- "database" (Log Horizon OP1)
- "Before My Body Is Dry" (Kill la Kill OST)
- "Out of Control" (Psycho-Pass OP2)
- "Maware! Setsugetsuka" (UMD ED)
- "Libera Me from Hell" (TTGL OST)
- "Sono Chi no Sadame" (JoJo pt 2 OP)
MEDALS
Bebop, Inferno Cop, Mugi, and Bert again finished at the top of the poll, so no changes there.
Next closest were Anno, Yamakan, Accelerator (despite the DON'T VOTE FOR ACCELERATOR message), and Tomoko.
STADIUM STUFF
Future stadium ideas
Most requested were Geofront/Tokyo-3, Honnouji Arena, and a giant Japanese school classroom.
Adboards
Most requested were Hyper Oats, Morning Lescue, NERV, and a 3DPD public service ad.
Rail banners
Most requested were "Your favorite anime is shit", "JIBUN WOOOOO", "EEEEEHH? NANDATTE?", "KyoAni Didn't Find A Way"
IF YOU COULD CHANGE ONE THING
With 200 suggestions they were bound to be all over the place, but here are some of the main themes.
Name changes
Change Colosal Titan's name to Bert | Change Colossal Titan to Bert | Change Colossal Titan's name to Bert | Colossal Titan name, change to Bert | Colossal Titan needs to be renamed into Bert. Spoiler all the animeonly fags. | Colossal Titan->Bert | Rename Collosal Titan to Bert | Renaming Titan to Bert | Requesting the Colossal Titan to be renamed Bert.
Best Girl Thread should be snail because she is (or Kaiki) | Replace Best Girl Thread's face with Kaiki or add him to roster. | remove not-so-memorable flavour of the season chars(ex.monokuma), upgrade bland ones(ex.best girl)
Considering both BGT and Colossal Titan finished close to the cut line (and Kaiki was close to being requested enough as a new player to make the team), we are going to rename them to Kaiki Best Girl and Bert Is A Titan respectively.
MOAR
More aggresive | More board meme players, less flavor of the month characters | more butts | more characters and less epin board culture | More cute girls | More dancing. Otherwise nothing. Our current manager is great. | more fanservice | More ganbare | more kill la kill best anime 201x | More little girls | More manga reps | More seasonal things | More variety, maybe change many players frm last year | More _actual_ players, sometimes they seem to stick for way too long after being irrelevant | Needs more Crate Criminal | Needs more little girls | NEEDS MORE MOE | Needs more moe. I know /c/ and /u/ will take most of it but come on, it's 2014. | Not enough autism. | Not enough cute girls doing cute things
Less
Less Autism | Less choking more winning | less flavour of the season players | Less seasonal anime characters. | Less shit characters | less "board culture" references because fuck your may mays | Fewer characters from entry level or crossboarder-tier shows | Fewer mandatory questions on these surveys
Do something but I don't know what
Give them a catchier goalhorn (No I don't have a good suggestion for this myself) | i'm not a fan of the anthem (rebuild a shit) but i can't think of a suitable replacement so whatever | the away kit I guess. But then again I dont have an alternative for it so meh.
NEVER CHANGE THIS ONE THING
This is why 4 players are going on permanent status
Accel as Goalkeep | Accel being removed | Accel not being goalkeeper. | Accelerator | accelerator | Accelerator | Accelerator | Accelerator | Accelerator | Accelerator | accelerator as a player | Accelerator as goalkeeper | Accelerator ever being removed | Bebop being the star player | bebop getting kicked out | Bebop Gold player | Brown mugi | Cowboy Bebop | Cowboy Bebop as gold / captain | Cowboy Bebop carrying that weight | Cowboy Bebop must never leave | Cowboy bebop. | Do not take off bebob or accelerator | Don't change Mugi | Don't change Mugi | For the love of Aleizer keep Accel in the goal | inferno cop | inferno cop | Inferno cop | Inferno Cup | Just keep Accel. | keep accelarator as goal keeper | Keep Bebop | Keep Bebop as captain | Keep Inferno cop | keep inferno cop on the roster | Keep Mugi and Bebop | Keep Mugi brown. | Mugi | Mugi | Mugi | Mugi | Mugi being a negro | mugi stays | Mugi stays no matter what | Mugi, Accel | Mugi's skin colour | Never let Cowboy Bebop be fired | Never remove Bebop, Accelerator, Mugi, Inferno Cop and Kenshiro from the team | Removing/weakening Accelerator | sacking bebop | Spike leaving. | taking mugi off the team
This is why we're probably not going to have a goalhorn/anthem poll next time either
/a/ should never have a goal horn other than Colours Flow. | Anthem | Anthem | Anthem and goalhorn | DONT CHANGE THE FUCKING ANTHEM | Goalhorn | goalhorn is perfect as it is | Jibun Wo Goalhorm | JIBUN WOOOO | JINBUUUUUU WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO | never change jibun wo | Please, don_t ever replace JIBUN WO. | the anthem | The anthem. Red Ambasadress fits perfectly. | The Gaolhorn is perfect and should never be changed | the goalhorn also bebop as captain | The goalhorn(s). | The music and Cowboy Bebop still being captain. | The themes, they're perfect | "Colours" should ALWAYS remain the goalhorn.
Blatant self-promotion
Make sure Firo isn't fired | Our teams way of handling things. (This survey, not even /sp/ are this organised) | Tactics and leadership. | The Leadership | Tottori doing the aesthetics
Gomennasai, I am Ken-sama
8man being removed. It wasn't his fault we lost to /wg/. It was the height abuse. | 8man. | grumpy | Keep 8man | Keep 8man on the team. | Keep ERU ERUFU | Keep Hora | Keep Korbo | Keep Korbo | Remove monstergirl. | Removing the original players
THE 2014 WINTER SQUAD (positions not yet confirmed)
|
|